
EU Inc. sitrep: the Commission got it right. Now pause the file and buy time, before it dies by a thousand cuts.
EU Inc. sitrep: the Commission got it right. Now pause the file and buy time, before it dies by a thousand cuts.
19.11.2026 - AustrianStartups is a founding member of Startups for Europe, the Brussels-based umbrella organisation for Europe’s national startup associations, where our CEO Hannah Wundsam sits on the board. Together with EU-INC, Startups for Europe has asked Commission President Ursula von der Leyen and the European Commission to withdraw the EU Inc. proposal. Here’s why, and what it means for us in Austria.
The short version
Let's start with something we don't get to say very often: the Commission got this one right.
The EU Inc. proposal from March isn't the full 28th regime we campaigned for, but it works. Founders could register where they like and operate everywhere, give their teams stock options that work across borders, wind a company down without a lawyer in every country, and file everything digitally in one place. We could have built on that.
The problem is what's happened since. In the Council, Member States are doing what they always do and protecting their own rules and their own competences. Parliament isn't much help either, because it's mostly busy fighting about codetermination. None of the changes looks dramatic on its own. Add them up and EU Inc. stops working. Death by a thousand paper cuts.
A few things follow from that.
The Commission isn't the problem this time, and we need to say that loudly. The public mood can easily tip into "Brussels failed again", and that would be wrong. If anything, the fix here is more Europe, not less.
The Council text is now the floor. It's finished, it hangs together, and it will dominate the trilogue. Realistically it only gets worse from here, and most of what's in it won't move.
Parliament won't rescue it on its own, and trilogues don't win back lost ground. Left alone, we end up with something close to the Council text, and founders won't use it.
So as part of Startups for Europe, and together with EU-INC, we’ve asked the Commission to withdraw the proposal. We know how that sounds. But it's the only institutional move that actually stops the clock and buys time. It gives the Commission room to realign Member States and Parliament, re-table, and fight for its own text: compromise where that's sensible, hold firm where the original design is what makes EU Inc. work.
Startups for Europe will support the Commission in Brussels. But the cuts came from Member States, and their positions are set in national capitals. That’s where the conversation needs to be reopened, including in Vienna.
What the Commission got right, and what the Council cut
Here's the side-by-side. The March proposal (COM(2026) 321) had the pieces that make a company form usable. The Council mandate of 19 October (ST 14376/26) weakened or removed every one of them, mostly to keep control in national hands.
|
What founders need |
Commission proposal: got it right |
Council mandate: cut |
|---|---|---|
|
Register anywhere, operate everywhere |
Real non-discrimination, with a high bar for exceptions |
Left in a recital only. Protection narrowed, formation carved out, and any national authority can act on "serious doubts" (Art 103a) |
|
Stock options (EU-ESO) |
For every company, taxed no worse than national plans |
Capped at 750 people or EUR 150m; equal tax treatment deleted |
|
Insolvency |
Simple digital wind-down (Chapter X) |
Deleted; back to national law |
|
Central registry |
On the path to one EU register (Art 34) |
Deleted, along with real-time tracking |
|
Digital formation |
Via a digital power of attorney |
Excluded; every director files in person with an EU eID |
|
Codetermination |
Rules of the home state apply |
New host-state mechanism |
|
Speed |
Live in 12 months |
21 months; digital tools not before July 2028 |
Source: EU-INC legal analysis of the Council mandate, draft of 5 November. See Annex A.
A thousand paper cuts
EU Inc. has one job: let you set up one company, once, and use it everywhere. That's how Delaware won. The Commission's text does that job. The Council's version breaks it in five places, and honestly any one of them would be enough to send founders back to Delaware.
-
Any Member State can now question where you're registered. Article 103a lets a host-country authority step in on "serious doubts", with no real limit on what it can do. Picture a Dutch EU Inc. whose founders live in Germany: that's exactly the company this hits, and no Series A investor wants that uncertainty.
-
Banks, registries and public bodies are allowed to treat you differently. The protection now only covers "economic activities", so when you expand into Germany you might still need a GmbH just to open a bank account or get into the land registry. The whole one-company idea is gone.
-
Stock options stop working when you grow. Cross 750 employees or EUR 150m in turnover and new hires can't get EU-ESO any more. On top of that, every country can tax it worse than its own national scheme.
-
There's no predictable way out. Insolvency goes back to national law, so an investor with three EU Incs in the portfolio deals with three different regimes.
-
It's neither digital nor single. The central registry is gone, digital formation is gone, and the digital tools only arrive in July 2028. Co-founders from outside the EU can't file, and banks will be doing KYC 27 times over.
Then there are the small cuts: yearly reporting on where you're based, shared office addresses treated as a red flag, both countries having to agree before you can list cross-border, host-state codetermination. Each one probably looks reasonable from a ministry in a national capital. Put together, they turn ordinary startup life into a compliance risk.
That's what frustrates us most. This file exists to strengthen the single market, and it's being rewritten to keep powers at home.
Why trilogues won't fix it
The EU-INC legal team went through the Council text line by line (it's in Annex A). To get back to something that works, 16 points need to go back to the Commission's version, and 12 of those are must-haves.
Trilogues don't do that. They trade a handful of open points; they don't reverse sixteen, most of them the Council's own additions. Member States insisted on Article 103a, the formation carve-out and the "limit or prohibit" wording for regulated sectors before they'd agree to anything, so they'll dig in. Parliament will spend its political capital on codetermination, not on where companies can register or how stock options work. And under time pressure, the Commission's role in trilogue is to help close a deal. It can't hold out alone against both co-legislators.
If we let it run on autopilot, we get the Council text, a couple of cosmetic wins and new codetermination rules from Parliament. A broken product with the EU Inc. name on it. That is unacceptable.
What we're asking for
We want the Commission to withdraw the proposal, so it has the time to fight for its own text.
Withdrawal is the only option that changes the outcome. Bringing back what makes EU Inc. work: free choice of registered office with real non-discrimination, EU-ESO without caps and with equal tax treatment, the central registry, digital formation and a fast start. Where compromise is reasonable, it should happen: tying public funding to real activity, requiring an EU-resident director, and leaving tax, labour and social security to national law don’t break what makes EU Inc. work.
In Brussels, Startups for Europe and EU-INC will back the Commission, publicly and behind closed doors, and work with MEPs on the parts that matter.
For AustrianStartups that means: we go back to our national parliament and policymakers and make sure the next text brings back what the Commission got right.
